• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Kentucky Center for Economic Policy

Kentucky Center for Economic Policy

   

  • About Us
  • Press Room
  • Donate
  • Summer Policy Institute 2023

Research That Works for Kentucky

  • Topics
    • Budget & Tax
    • Criminal Justice
    • Economic Security
    • Education
    • Health Care
    • Jobs & The Economy
  • Types
    • News
    • Op-Ed
    • Research

   

  • About Us
  • Press Room
  • Donate
  • Summer Policy Institute 2023

Copyright © 2023 KyPolicy Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Sitemap

Analysis

Senate Pension Bill Also Breaks Inviolable Contract

Jason Bailey | April 11, 2019

When the governor vetoed House Bill 358, the legislation affecting pension costs for quasi-governmental organizations like community mental health centers and regional universities, his primary stated objection was that it “violates the moral and legal obligation” to retirees of these agencies. He told a radio show that we should “take out the parts that are illegal and then repass the thing.”

The bill certainly was illegal, as we noted here. However, the governor also wrote in a letter at the end of the session that he would sign the Senate version of HB 358. When the Senate president issued a statement calling the governor’s veto “perplexing,” the governor responded that he was also “perplexed.” He pointed back to the Senate proposal and claimed it “did not include the blatant violation of the inviolable contract that was included in the final version.”

More On Budget & Tax: Shorting State Workers’ Pay Hurts Us All

We all should be perplexed, because both versions of HB 358 are at odds with the inviolable contract. The violation in the Senate version was a major reason the House refused to go along with it.

The Senate plan put in place a “hard freeze” on the benefits of current employees. They could no longer accrue benefits in the pension plan, and would be moved to a 401k-style defined contribution (DC) plan for the remainder of their careers. A 20-year employee who plans to work 30 years, for example, could stand to lose an estimated 53 percent of his or her defined benefit pension, and the DC plan would not come close to making up for the loss, as shown in the table below.

A story in The Courier-Journal attributed HB 358’s sponsor as saying “many House members are concerned that the Senate approach would significantly reduce the pension benefits anticipated by many current employees of the affected groups.”

The Tier 1 and Tier 2 employees who would receive this cut are protected under the inviolable contract. State law says their benefits “shall not be subject to reduction or impairment by alteration, amendment, or repeal.” There are 6,700 such employees at quasi-governmental organizations, as indicated in the graph below.

Kentucky needs ways to help quasi-governmental organizations that also safeguard the retirement systems, pass legal muster and protect the retirement security of employees. The legislature should continue to freeze the rate at which quasis are paying pension costs for now, then realign actuarial assumptions so they are reasonable and generate revenue for contributions by cleaning up tax breaks in the 2020 General Assembly. The options being considered by the legislature won’t get us where we need to go.

FacebookTweetLinkedInEmail

Primary Sidebar

Get KyPolicy news updates in your inbox

Sign Up

Sidebar

Perspectives

Shorting State Workers’ Pay Hurts Us All

Cutting Bourbon Industry Taxes Harms the Communities That Sustain It

Lawmakers Should Help Our Kids, Not Lock More Up in Failing Juvenile System

Income Tax Reduction Is Another Blow to Rural Kentucky

Kentucky Should Not Volunteer for Greater Inequality by Becoming More Like Tennessee

Other Budget & Tax Items

Untitled design 3

Analysis

HB 444 Leaves $110 Million On the Table for State Worker Pay

Untitled design 4

Analysis

‘Transplant’ Bill Would Give Large Windfall to Companies Recruiting Remote Workers

FYyX9deXkAIV AM

Analysis

Eastern Kentucky Needs Legislature’s Help to Address Post-Flood Housing Crisis

Ky. Policy

Footer

Research that works for Kentucky

433 Chestnut Street, Berea, KY 40403

Phone: 859-756-4605

General information and inquiries: info@kypolicy.org

   

Help us make the facts free and accessible to everyone. That’s how Kentucky will thrive.

Donate

  • Topics
    • Budget & Tax
    • Criminal Justice
    • Economic Security
    • Education
    • Health Care
    • Jobs & The Economy
  • Work
    • News
    • Op-Ed
    • Research
  • About Us
  • Press Room
  • Contact

Get KyPolicy news updates in your inbox

Sign Up

Copyright © 2023 KyPolicy Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Sitemap

made by P&P
Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!